Serious Router Problems

[Kamikaze]

I can't solve my router problem so far.. I opened the following ports:
6112
6667
28900
26857
29920
6500
27900
27901
29910

and my firewall is down.. I am using a digitus router... hell don't buy that again.. so can anyone help me, it seems open the ports and shuting down the wall won't do the trick :werd:

[ÜberJumper]

What's the problem?

[Kamikaze]

What's the problem?
My problem is, when I open up a game, noone is able to join.

[ÜberJumper]

Your router may not be one of the ones tested to work with gamespy's nat negotiation.

Do you have a DMZ option for your router?

[Kamikaze]

Yes I do, but actually this one is automatically set to off, when I turn of the firewall....

[Smay]

So I`m not the only one :/. I can join most servers but I can´t create my own one. Players are able to see the server but simply can´t connect. I already forwarded all necessary ports as discribed in the readme file.
I`m using a fli4l router, thats a linux based routersystem running on an old Pentium 75´s floppy drive.
http://www.fli4l.de/e_index.htm
Usually it works perfectly and it offers a lot more than a standard router :/

[ÜberJumper]

Post your warnings.log after you host a game and someone tries to join please.

[Smay]

Here it comes :p
192.168.168.11 is my internal IP
--------------

W40K started at 2004-10-05 00:53
OS NT 5.1, 2048MB Physical Memory
RUN-OPTIONS
WORKING-DIR D:\Spiele\DoW
USER Stefan1

00:53:46.0 MATHBOX -- Version=5, Cpu=AMD Athlon:f=6,m=10, Mode=SSE
00:53:46.0 GAME -- Warhammer, 1.01, Build 57117.44353
00:53:46.0 GAME -- Available memory: 2047MB RAM, 3895MB Pagefile
00:53:46.2 State::State - set socket send buffer to 131072
00:53:46.2 State::State - set socket receive buffer to 131072
00:53:46.2 HostState - 192.168.168.11:6112 / 192.168.168.11:6112
00:53:46.2 Session : Now Host
00:53:46.2 Session : We are now a Host
00:53:46.2 PeerState - 192.168.168.11:6112 / 192.168.168.11:6112
00:53:46.2 PeerState::ConnectCallbackHost - connecting to host at 255.255.255.255:6112
00:53:46.3 GSTransport::Connect - GT2AddressError
00:53:46.5 SPOOGE - Driver[Dx9 : Hardware TnL] on adapter[0], version[4,32]
00:53:46.9 SPDx9 -- Driver Name = ati2dvag.dll Device = \\.\DISPLAY1 Desc = RADEON 9700 PRO
00:53:46.9 SPDx9 -- Driver Vendor = 0x1002 Device = 0x4E44 SubSys = 0x00021002 Rev = 0x0000
00:53:46.9 SPDx9 -- Driver Version Product = 0x0006 Version = 0x000E SubVersion = 0x000A Build = 0x193A (6458)
00:53:46.9 SPDx9 -- Driver GUID = {D7B71EE2-0D04-11CF-886A-0820A1C2CB35}
00:53:47.0 SPOOGE -- 359.00MB available texture memory
00:53:47.0 SPOOGE -- 359.00MB available texture memory
00:53:47.3 GAME -- Beginning FE
00:53:48.5 MOVIE -- Opening movie 'movies:relic_intro.lua'
00:53:50.1 MOVIE -- Closing movie 'movies:relic_intro.lua'
00:53:50.1 MOVIE -- Opening movie 'movies:dow_intro.lua'
00:53:50.9 MOVIE -- Closing movie 'movies:dow_intro.lua'
00:53:51.0 MOD -- (mod manager) W40k, 1.0
00:53:51.1 MOD -- (mod manager) Failed to load Folder 'W40k\Data_Shared_Textures\Full'
00:53:51.1 MOD -- (mod manager) Failed to load Folder 'W40k\Data_Sound\Full'
00:53:51.1 MOD -- (mod manager) Failed to load Folder 'W40k\Data_Whm\High'
00:53:58.1 GAME -- Using player profile Smay
00:54:03.5 EnterMultiplayerForm registering with lobby
00:54:03.7 Lobby - LOE_LobbySystemConnectionResult received
00:54:06.5 GameSpyLogonForm registering with lobby
00:54:07.9 Lobby - LIE_Initialise received
00:54:07.9 GSPeer::Logon - 7 Smay
00:54:08.1 App : Creating session
00:54:10.2 GSPeer::Dispatch::OnChatConnect 1, 'Smay-thq'
00:54:11.0 GSPeer::Dispatch::OnCDAuthenticate - 1
00:54:11.0 GSPeer::Dispatch::OnCDAuthenticate - Authenticated
00:54:11.0 Lobby - LOE_LogInResult received
00:54:11.0 Lobby - LIE_CheckForPatch received
00:54:11.0 GSPatcher::CheckForPatch before
00:54:11.0 GSPatcher::CheckForPatch after
00:54:11.6 Lobby - received patch check result from gamespy 0, ,
00:54:11.6 Lobby - LOE_PatchQueryResult received
00:54:11.6 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
00:54:11.6 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
00:54:11.6 Lobby - LIE_PatchQueryResult received
00:54:11.8 Lobby - LIE_GetNews received
00:54:12.1 Lobby - LOE_Download_Complete received
00:54:12.3 Lobby - LOE_News received
00:54:12.5 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:54:12.6 Lobby - LOE_Download_Complete received
00:54:15.8 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:54:17.5 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:54:33.9 GameSetupNetwork registering with lobby
00:54:34.2 GameSetupNetwork registering with lobby
00:54:37.4 Lobby - LIE_HostGame received
00:54:37.4 GSPeer::OnServerClear
00:54:37.4 App : Closing session
00:54:37.4 App : Creating session
00:54:37.4 Lobby - hosting on port 6112
00:54:37.4 HostState - 217.86.173.55:6112 / 192.168.168.11:6112
00:54:37.4 Lobby - LIE_ClearBanList received
00:54:37.5 Session : Now Host
00:54:37.5 Session : We are now a Host
00:54:37.6 Lobby - Sending a player update message to all players
00:54:37.6 Lobby - host created
00:54:37.6 local 5b730b80
00:54:37.6 Lobby - LOE_JoinHostResult received
00:54:37.6 GSPeer::SessionHost( )
00:54:37.6 Lobby - Ignoring New Peer for local player
00:54:37.6 GameSetupNetwork registering with lobby
00:54:38.0 QRPublicAddressCallback - 934106841:61402
00:55:34.5 QRNatNegotiateCallback
00:55:34.5 NAT Negotiation - Incoming Request, cookie is 36781508
00:55:35.3 NAT Negotiation - Progress - connect ping
00:55:50.3 QRNatNegotiateCallback
00:55:50.3 NAT Negotiation - Incoming Request, cookie is -1777076178
00:55:50.7 NAT Negotiation - Progress - connect ping
00:55:55.6 Lobby - LIE_QuitGame received
00:55:55.6 GSPeer::SessionGetList()
00:55:55.9 App : Closing session
00:55:55.9 GSPeer::SessionCancel
00:55:55.9 Lobby - LIE_ClearBanList received
00:55:55.9 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
00:55:55.9 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
00:55:56.0 GSPeer::OnServerClear
00:55:56.0 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:55:56.0 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:55:56.3 Lobby - LIE_GetNews received
00:55:56.3 Lobby - LOE_News received
00:55:57.4 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:55:59.5 GAME -- Ending FE
00:55:59.6 MOD -- (mod manager) shutting down
00:56:00.1 SPOOGE -- 358.00MB available texture memory
00:56:00.1 SPOOGE -- 359.00MB available texture memory

Application closed with error code -1

[Kamikaze]

00:56:58.9 MATHBOX -- Version=5, Cpu=AMD Athlon:f=6,m=8, Mode=SSE
00:56:59.2 GAME -- Warhammer, 1.01, Build 57117.44353
00:56:59.2 GAME -- Available memory: 1023MB RAM, 2411MB Pagefile
00:56:59.3 State::State - set socket send buffer to 131072
00:56:59.3 State::State - set socket receive buffer to 131072
00:56:59.4 HostState - 192.168.2.100:6112 / 192.168.2.100:6112
00:56:59.4 Session : Now Host
00:56:59.4 Session : We are now a Host
00:56:59.4 PeerState - 192.168.2.100:6112 / 192.168.2.100:6112
00:56:59.4 PeerState::ConnectCallbackHost - connecting to host at 255.255.255.255:6112
00:56:59.4 GSTransport::Connect - GT2AddressError
00:56:59.7 SPOOGE - Driver[Dx9 : Hardware TnL] on adapter[0], version[4,32]
00:57:00.3 SPDx9 -- Driver Name = nv4_disp.dll Device = \\.\DISPLAY1 Desc = NVIDIA GeForce3 Ti 200
00:57:00.3 SPDx9 -- Driver Vendor = 0x10DE Device = 0x0201 SubSys = 0x40571043 Rev = 0x00A3
00:57:00.3 SPDx9 -- Driver Version Product = 0x0006 Version = 0x000E SubVersion = 0x000A Build = 0x1821 (6177)
00:57:00.3 SPDx9 -- Driver GUID = {D7B71E3E-4141-11CF-D26B-5D6002C2CB35}
00:57:00.4 SPOOGE -- 105.00MB available texture memory
00:57:00.4 SPOOGE -- 105.00MB available texture memory
00:57:01.3 GAME -- Beginning FE
00:57:03.2 MOVIE -- Opening movie 'movies:relic_intro.lua'
00:57:03.7 APP -- Resetting fp control word.
00:57:15.7 MOVIE -- Closing movie 'movies:relic_intro.lua'
00:57:15.7 MOVIE -- Opening movie 'movies:dow_intro.lua'
00:57:16.8 MOVIE -- Closing movie 'movies:dow_intro.lua'
00:57:17.3 MOD -- (mod manager) W40k, 1.0
00:57:18.0 MOD -- (mod manager) Failed to load Folder 'W40k\Data_Shared_Textures\Full'
00:57:18.0 MOD -- (mod manager) Failed to load Folder 'W40k\Data_Sound\Low'
00:57:18.0 MOD -- (mod manager) Failed to load Folder 'W40k\Data_Whm\High'
00:57:30.6 Badge 'BADGES:symbol.tga' is not 64x64 pixels!
00:57:30.8 Banner 'BANNERS:kamikazeb.tga' is not 64x96 pixels!
00:57:30.8 Banner 'BANNERS:kamikaze_weissb.tga' is not 64x96 pixels!
00:57:30.8 Banner 'BANNERS:symbolb.tga' is not 64x96 pixels!
00:57:30.8 Banner 'BANNERS:Untitled-1gh.tga' is not 64x96 pixels!
00:57:30.8 Banner 'BANNERS:Untitled-2b.tga' is not 64x96 pixels!
00:57:30.9 Banner 'BANNERS:Untitled566-1.tga' is not 64x96 pixels!
00:57:31.1 GAME -- Using player profile Kamikaze
00:57:35.0 EnterMultiplayerForm registering with lobby
00:57:35.2 Lobby - LOE_LobbySystemConnectionResult received
00:57:37.7 GameSpyLogonForm registering with lobby
00:57:39.4 Lobby - LIE_Initialise received
00:57:39.4 GSPeer::Logon - 7 KamikazeX
00:57:42.8 App : Creating session
00:57:47.9 GSPeer::Dispatch::OnChatConnect 1, 'KamikazeX-thq'
00:57:49.8 GSPeer::Dispatch::OnCDAuthenticate - 1
00:57:49.8 GSPeer::Dispatch::OnCDAuthenticate - Authenticated
00:57:49.8 Lobby - LOE_LogInResult received
00:57:49.8 Lobby - LIE_CheckForPatch received
00:57:49.8 GSPatcher::CheckForPatch before
00:57:49.8 GSPatcher::CheckForPatch after
00:57:51.3 Lobby - received patch check result from gamespy 0, ,
00:57:51.3 Lobby - LOE_PatchQueryResult received
00:57:51.3 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
00:57:51.3 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
00:57:51.3 Lobby - LIE_PatchQueryResult received
00:57:52.6 Lobby - LIE_GetNews received
00:57:54.2 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:57:56.1 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
00:57:56.6 Lobby - LOE_Download_Complete received
00:57:57.3 Lobby - LOE_News received
00:57:57.9 GameSetupNetwork registering with lobby
00:57:58.8 GameSetupNetwork registering with lobby
00:57:58.8 Lobby - LOE_Download_Complete received
00:58:07.7 Lobby - LIE_HostGame received
00:58:07.7 GSPeer::OnServerClear
00:58:07.7 App : Closing session
00:58:07.7 App : Creating session
00:58:07.7 Lobby - hosting on port 6112
00:58:07.7 HostState - 217.9.51.226:6112 / 192.168.2.100:6112
00:58:07.7 Lobby - LIE_ClearBanList received
00:58:07.8 Session : Now Host
00:58:07.8 Session : We are now a Host
00:58:07.9 Lobby - Sending a player update message to all players
00:58:07.9 Lobby - host created
00:58:07.9 local 5b730b80
00:58:07.9 Lobby - LOE_JoinHostResult received
00:58:07.9 GSPeer::SessionHost( )
00:58:08.5 Lobby - Ignoring New Peer for local player
00:58:08.5 GameSetupNetwork registering with lobby
00:58:09.4 QRPublicAddressCallback - -499971623:56511
01:00:09.1 QRNatNegotiateCallback
01:00:09.1 NAT Negotiation - Incoming Request, cookie is 1534266240
01:00:11.8 NAT Negotiation - Progress - initialise acknowledged
01:00:47.5 Lobby - LIE_QuitGame received
01:00:47.5 GSPeer::SessionGetList()
01:00:48.5 App : Closing session
01:00:48.5 GSPeer::SessionCancel
01:00:48.5 Lobby - LIE_ClearBanList received
01:00:48.5 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
01:00:48.5 GameSpyLobbyForm registering with lobby
01:00:48.7 GSPeer::OnServerClear
01:00:48.7 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
01:00:48.7 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
01:00:52.7 Lobby - LIE_GetNews received
01:00:52.7 Lobby - LOE_News received
01:00:54.1 Lobby - LIE_StopAutoMatch received
01:00:56.1 GAME -- Ending FE
01:00:56.2 MOD -- (mod manager) shutting down
01:00:56.4 SPOOGE -- 103.00MB available texture memory
01:00:56.4 SPOOGE -- 104.00MB available texture memory

[Anakaris]

Did you include UDP traffic in those port forwardings also?

[Kamikaze]

Did you include UDP traffic in those port forwardings also?
Yep UDP is in...

[Anakaris]

Have you tried going from modem to your computer to see if it would allow you to host?

You know remove the router for a while just to rule it out.

[Kamikaze]

Yeah, without the router, it's no problem at all.

[Anakaris]

Have you checked to see on the manufactures website to see if there's any newer firmware for it?

[Kamikaze]

Yes, actually I did.

[Anakaris]

Well then I guess your router doesn't handle NAT for DoW very well then. Nothing you can really do about it besides getting something like a Dlink. I have one, allows me to host all the games I need.

[chobo321321]

Go to this website, and click on all ports. It will show you which ports are actually open, stealthed, or closed.

https://grc.com/x/ne.dll?bh0bkyd2

In your router setup screen make sure when you forward a port it's for your machines internal IP address (in case you have more comps connected).